Examiner's comment
Assessment of extended writing as in Q6, Q11 and Q18 differentiated well. Weaker responses to these questions suggest that students need to focus on developing their higher order skills. Students should take time to read the specific demands of each question carefully, rather than simply writing everything they know about the topic. This was particularly the case for Question 6, where much time was wasted in lengthy descriptions of the procedures of Milgram’s original study. Just like the Asch question in 2016, this was a question where students needed to select the relevant aspects of research. Students often wrote detailed and unnecessarily lengthy descriptions of Milgram’s original study, before getting round to outlining the relevant variations thereby answering the question. Students’ knowledge of research into proximity, location and uniform was often good, however relatively few students addressed the second part of the question, ie “what this tells us about why people obey”. Students need to read each question carefully and make sure they deal with all aspects of it to access Level 3 or Level 4. Better answers made use of other studies to support or challenge Milgram’s findings. Good use was made of Hofling’s study to challenge Milgram’s findings relating to proximity. Bickman’s findings regarding the power of uniform were also used effectively. While elements of Zimbardo’s prison simulation could have been made relevant to this question, such material was often used ineffectively. Students should also be aware that the terms “obedience” and “conformity” are not interchangeable, and that they mean very different things.