Clinical psychology and mental health: key studies
11 studies. Tap a card to flip it, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back every round; cards you know come back less often. Progress is saved in this browser. Terms deck · Match-up game · Back to the topic
Rosenhan and Seligman (1989), failure to function adequately
Aim To define abnormality by the inability to cope with everyday life.
Method A set of criteria: personal distress, maladaptive behaviour, irrationality, unpredictability, observer discomfort and violation of moral standards.
Findings A person is abnormal when they cannot maintain basic hygiene, hold a job, or keep relationships, and when several criteria apply.
Conclusion Abnormality is about the consequences of behaviour for the person.
Evaluation Takes the person's experience into account; some people with disorders function well (high-functioning); judging 'adequate' functioning is subjective and may be used against lifestyle choices.
Examiners say Definitions questions are answered well; evaluation needs a developed point, e.g. 'it ignores people who are distressed but functioning'.
Jahoda (1958), deviation from ideal mental health
Aim To define mental health positively rather than by the absence of symptoms.
Method Six criteria: no symptoms or distress, rational and accurate self-perception, self-actualisation, good self-esteem, independence, successful work and relationships, coping with stress.
Findings The further someone is from these ideals, the more abnormal they are.
Conclusion Abnormality is deviation from an ideal.
Evaluation Comprehensive and positive; the criteria are culture-bound (independence is a Western value); almost nobody meets all six, so it sets an unrealistically high standard.
Examiners say The common error in 'evaluate deviation from ideal mental health' was evaluating a different definition.
Mowrer (1960), two-process model of phobias
Aim To explain how phobias start and why they persist.
Method A behaviourist model combining two kinds of learning.
Findings Phobias are acquired by classical conditioning (Watson and Rayner's Little Albert: a white rat paired with a loud noise) and maintained by operant conditioning, because avoiding the feared object reduces anxiety (negative reinforcement).
Conclusion Phobias are learned and can be unlearned.
Evaluation Explains why phobias persist and led to effective treatments; cannot explain phobias with no traumatic event, or why some frightening experiences do not produce phobias; ignores evolutionary preparedness (Seligman) and cognitive aspects.
Examiners say The two most popular limitations in reports: phobias without trauma, and biological preparedness for snakes and spiders rather than cars.
Wolpe (1958), systematic desensitisation
Aim To treat phobias by replacing fear with relaxation.
Method Three parts: an anxiety hierarchy from least to most feared situations; relaxation training (breathing, muscle relaxation, imagery) based on reciprocal inhibition; gradual exposure, moving up the hierarchy only when relaxed at each step.
Findings Gilroy et al: 42 spider-phobic patients treated with three 45-minute sessions were less fearful than a relaxation-only group at 3 and 33 months.
Conclusion Counter-conditioning replaces the fear response with relaxation.
Evaluation Effective and acceptable to patients, with low drop-out; takes longer than flooding; may be less effective for phobias with an evolutionary basis; can be done with virtual reality.
Examiners say Application questions (Saira and cats) need the three components applied to the stem: a hierarchy of cat situations, relaxation taught, and gradual exposure. Reports flag students who outline theory instead of the therapy.
Flooding
Aim To treat a phobia by immediate full exposure.
Method The patient is exposed to the most frightening situation at once, without a hierarchy, and stays until the anxiety subsides (extinction), because the fear response cannot be sustained and the avoidance that maintained it is prevented.
Findings Often works in one long session; Ougrin found it as effective as other treatments and quicker.
Conclusion Extinction of the conditioned fear response removes the phobia.
Evaluation Fast and cheap; highly traumatic, so many patients do not complete it; less effective for social phobias, which have cognitive aspects; informed consent is essential.
Examiners say For 2 marks: immediate exposure plus staying until calm or exhausted. 'Why is SD more successful than flooding?' wants a reason developed: lower drop-out because it is less traumatic.
Beck (1967), negative triad
Aim To explain depression in terms of thinking.
Method A cognitive theory based on clinical observation.
Findings Depressed people have faulty information processing (focusing on the negative, black-and-white thinking), negative self-schemas from childhood, and the negative triad: a negative view of the self, the world and the future.
Conclusion Cognitive vulnerability leads to depression.
Evaluation Supported by Grazioli and Terry (cognitive vulnerability predicted post-natal depression in 65 pregnant women); forms the basis of CBT; does not explain all aspects, such as anger or hallucinations; may be a consequence rather than a cause.
Examiners say The 'complete the triad' diagram asks for self, world and future. 'Describe one cognitive explanation' is answered well, but excessive length is noted.
Ellis (1962), ABC model
Aim To explain depression as the result of irrational beliefs.
Method A: an activating event; B: the belief, rational or irrational; C: the consequence, healthy or unhealthy emotions.
Findings Irrational beliefs such as musturbation (I must succeed), utopianism (life must be fair) and I-can't-stand-it-itis lead to depression after negative events.
Conclusion It is the belief about an event, not the event, that causes depression.
Evaluation Only explains reactive depression; led to rational emotive behaviour therapy, which has practical value; blames the patient for their thinking.
Examiners say Outline for 4 marks: name and explain each letter, and give an example of an irrational belief.
Cognitive behaviour therapy for depression
Aim To treat depression by changing irrational thinking.
Method Assessment of the patient's problems; identifying negative thoughts (Beck) or irrational beliefs (Ellis); challenging them through empirical disputing (where is the evidence?), logical disputing and pragmatic disputing; homework such as behavioural activation and keeping a thought diary ('patient as scientist').
Findings March et al: CBT as effective as antidepressants after 36 weeks (81% improved), with the combination best (86%).
Conclusion Changing cognitions changes mood.
Evaluation Effective and lasting; requires motivation, which severely depressed patients may lack; the quality of the therapist relationship may matter more than the technique (Rosenzweig); focuses on the present and may ignore circumstances.
Examiners say 'Describe a strategy used in CBT' is answered badly when students describe the theory; name a technique (empirical disputing, homework) and say what the therapist does.
Biological explanations of OCD
Aim To explain OCD through genes and the brain.
Method Family, twin and candidate-gene studies and brain scans.
Findings Genetic: Lewis found 37% of OCD patients had a parent with OCD; Nestadt's twin review gave 68% concordance for identical twins and 31% for non-identical; candidate genes include the SERT gene (serotonin transport) and COMT; OCD is polygenic with different combinations in different people (aetiologically heterogeneous). Neural: low serotonin; abnormal functioning of the orbitofrontal cortex and basal ganglia (the worry circuit).
Conclusion OCD has a strong biological basis.
Evaluation Twin evidence is strong but concordance is not 100%, so environment matters (Cromer: over half had a traumatic event); candidate genes have small effects; the serotonin link may reflect co-morbid depression; led to effective drug treatment.
Examiners say Application (Bob's brain scan and family history) needs both strands applied: genetic inheritance and the neural explanation. 'Describe one biological explanation' varied in accuracy; be specific about which gene or brain region.
Drug treatment of OCD
Aim To reduce OCD symptoms by correcting neurotransmitter levels.
Method SSRIs (e.g. fluoxetine, 20 mg daily) block the reuptake of serotonin at the synapse so that more remains available; typically 3–4 months to take effect, often combined with CBT. Alternatives: tricyclics (clomipramine) and SNRIs if SSRIs fail.
Findings Soomro et al reviewed 17 studies and found SSRIs more effective than placebos, with about 70% of patients improving.
Conclusion Raising serotonin reduces obsessions and anxiety.
Evaluation Cost-effective and non-disruptive; side-effects (indigestion, loss of libido, and for clomipramine more serious effects) cause drop-out; symptoms return if the drug is stopped; some evidence of publication bias and drug-company influence.
Examiners say Full marks need the mechanism: serotonin, reuptake blocked, more available. Reports note confusion between SSRIs and other drug types.
Watson and Rayner (1920), Little Albert
Aim To show that a fear can be conditioned.
Method A nine-month-old boy was shown a white rat; whenever he reached for it a steel bar was struck behind his head.
Findings After several pairings Albert cried at the rat alone, and the fear generalised to other furry objects.
Conclusion Phobias can be learned by classical conditioning.
Evaluation Single participant; the fear was not removed, which raises ethical issues; shows generalisation and stimulus association.
Examiners say Use the terms NS, UCS, UCR and CS/CR when applying it to a stem (Stan stuck in a lift).
Work with an AQA psychology tutor
Know the studies but not scoring on the essays? That's what a tutor fixes.