Attachment: key studies
12 studies. Tap a card to flip it, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back every round; cards you know come back less often. Progress is saved in this browser. Terms deck · Match-up game · Back to the topic
Meltzoff and Moore (1977), interactional synchrony
Aim To see whether infants imitate adult facial expressions.
Method An adult displayed one of three facial expressions or a hand gesture to infants as young as two weeks; responses were filmed and judged by independent observers.
Findings Infants' expressions and gestures matched the adult's more than chance.
Conclusion Interactional synchrony begins very early and may be the basis for attachment.
Evaluation Filming allows inter-observer reliability; infants' movements are hard to interpret, and later studies (Koepke et al) failed to replicate; Isabella et al found high synchrony linked to better attachment quality.
Examiners say Reciprocity is turn-taking in response to each other; synchrony is simultaneous mirroring. Definitions must separate the two.
Schaffer and Emerson (1964), stages of attachment
Aim To identify the stages at which attachments form and to whom.
Method 60 working-class Glasgow infants were visited at home every month for a year and again at 18 months; mothers reported separation and stranger anxiety.
Findings Specific attachments appeared at around 7 months, usually to the most responsive adult rather than the one who fed them; by 10 months most had multiple attachments; by 18 months 31% had five or more.
Conclusion Attachment develops in stages: asocial, indiscriminate, specific, multiple.
Evaluation Longitudinal and in a natural setting, with good external validity; relies on mothers' reports, which may be biased; one sample from one city and time; the asocial stage is hard to study.
Examiners say The finding that infants attached to the most responsive adult, not the feeder, is a standard criticism of learning theory.
Schaffer and Emerson (1964), role of the father
Aim To see when fathers become attachment figures.
Method Same Glasgow sample.
Findings Only 3% of infants attached to the father first; 27% jointly with the mother; by 18 months 75% had an attachment to the father.
Conclusion Fathers are usually secondary attachment figures.
Evaluation Grossmann et al found the father's play quality in infancy predicted adolescent attachment, suggesting a distinct role; Field found fathers as primary caregivers behave like mothers, so the role depends on responsiveness, not gender.
Examiners say Questions ask about the father's 'role', so evidence for a distinct play-based role and for primary-caregiver fathers both score.
Lorenz (1935), imprinting
Aim To study attachment in animals.
Method Half a clutch of goose eggs hatched with the mother, half in an incubator where the first moving object they saw was Lorenz; the groups were then mixed.
Findings The incubator goslings followed Lorenz everywhere; imprinting happened within a critical period of a few hours; it later affected mate choice (sexual imprinting).
Conclusion Attachment in birds is innate, rapid and tied to a critical period.
Evaluation Birds differ from mammals; Guiton's chickens imprinted on rubber gloves but later learned to prefer chickens, so imprinting may not be irreversible; influenced Bowlby's critical period.
Examiners say The 'Researcher A/Researcher B' question wants Lorenz with geese and Harlow with rhesus monkeys, and which found what.
Harlow (1958), contact comfort
Aim To test whether attachment is based on food or comfort.
Method 16 rhesus monkeys were reared with two wire 'mothers', one with a feeding bottle and one covered in soft cloth.
Findings Monkeys spent most time with the cloth mother regardless of which fed them, and ran to it when frightened; as adults they were socially abnormal and poor parents if reared without a real mother.
Conclusion Contact comfort, not food, is the basis of attachment; early maternal deprivation has lasting effects.
Evaluation Practical value for social work and animal care; the two mothers differed in face as well as cloth, a confounding variable; serious ethical costs; generalising from monkeys to humans is limited.
Examiners say A criticism 'apart from ethics' of using animals: human attachment involves language and culture, so the mechanisms may differ.
Dollard and Miller (1950), learning theory of attachment
Aim To explain attachment through conditioning.
Method A theory derived from behaviourist principles.
Findings Classical conditioning: the caregiver (neutral stimulus) is paired with food (unconditioned stimulus) until the caregiver alone produces pleasure. Operant conditioning: crying is reinforced by feeding; the caregiver is negatively reinforced by the crying stopping. Food is a primary drive, attachment a secondary drive.
Conclusion Attachment is learned, with food as the key.
Evaluation Contradicted by Harlow (comfort over food) and Schaffer and Emerson (attachment to responsive adults); ignores reciprocity and synchrony; some learning may matter through social learning (Hay and Vespo).
Examiners say 'Briefly evaluate learning theory' needs the counter-evidence explained, not just named.
Bowlby (1958, 1969), monotropic theory
Aim To explain attachment as an evolved behaviour.
Method A theory drawing on ethology.
Findings Attachment is innate and adaptive; infants form one special attachment (monotropy) with the law of continuity and the law of accumulated separation; social releasers (smiling, crying) elicit care; there is a critical (later sensitive) period of about two years; the first attachment forms an internal working model that shapes later relationships.
Conclusion Attachment keeps the infant close to a carer for survival and provides a template for later relationships.
Evaluation Support from Brazelton (social releasers) and Bailey et al (internal working model: mothers' own attachment matched their infants'); monotropy is questioned by Schaffer and Emerson's multiple attachments; socially sensitive (blame for working mothers); temperament may explain continuity instead (Kagan).
Examiners say 'Explain the role of the internal working model' discriminated well: say it is a mental template of the first relationship that is carried into friendships, romantic relationships and parenting.
Ainsworth (1970), Strange Situation
Aim To measure the quality of attachment.
Method A controlled observation of 100 American infants through eight 3-minute episodes: play, stranger enters, mother leaves, mother returns, infant alone, stranger returns, mother returns. Behaviours measured: proximity seeking, exploration and secure-base behaviour, stranger anxiety, separation anxiety, response to reunion.
Findings Secure (type B) 60–75%: explore, moderate separation and stranger anxiety, easily comforted. Insecure-avoidant (A) 20–25%: explore freely, little anxiety, ignore the mother on return. Insecure-resistant (C) 3%: little exploration, intense anxiety, resist comfort on return.
Conclusion Attachment type can be reliably classified from infant behaviour.
Evaluation Good inter-rater reliability (Bick et al, 94%); predictive validity (secure infants do better later); culture-bound (Takahashi: Japanese infants rarely left alone); may measure the relationship, not the child; a fourth type (disorganised) was added by Main and Solomon.
Examiners say Reports note students who write about attachment types when asked for the behaviours measured, and the reverse. 'Identify' a type needs only the name; 'outline the behaviour' needs reunion behaviour for each child.
Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg (1988), cultural variations
Aim To compare attachment types across cultures.
Method A meta-analysis of 32 Strange Situation studies in eight countries, nearly 2,000 infants.
Findings Secure was the most common type everywhere (from 50% in China to 75% in Britain); avoidant was more common in Germany, resistant in Israel and Japan; variation within countries was 1.5 times greater than between them.
Conclusion Attachment patterns are broadly universal, with cultural differences in the insecure types.
Evaluation Large sample; the studies compared countries rather than cultures; the Strange Situation is an American tool and may be invalid elsewhere (imposed etic); later studies (Simonelli in Italy) show patterns changing over time.
Examiners say 'Outline one example of cultural variation' needs a comparison: e.g. more resistant infants in Japan than in Britain, linked to childrearing. 'A limitation of van Ijzendoorn' was one of the most unattempted questions: the within-country variation is the one to learn.
Bowlby (1944), 44 thieves and maternal deprivation
Aim To test whether early separation from the mother causes affectionless psychopathy.
Method 44 adolescent thieves were interviewed and their families assessed for early separations, and compared with 44 non-criminal but emotionally disturbed teenagers.
Findings 14 thieves were affectionless psychopaths and 12 of those had experienced prolonged separation in the first two years; only 2 of the control group had.
Conclusion Prolonged separation in the critical period can cause emotional and intellectual damage, including affectionless psychopathy.
Evaluation Bowlby conducted the interviews himself (researcher bias); correlational; later work distinguishes deprivation from privation (Rutter) and shows recovery is possible (Koluchová twins); Lewis's larger replication found no link.
Examiners say Criticising the 44 thieves study is not the same as criticising the theory of maternal deprivation; reports repeatedly make this point.
Rutter et al (2011), English and Romanian Adoptee study
Aim To see whether good care can reverse the effects of institutionalisation.
Method 165 Romanian orphans adopted into British families were assessed at ages 4, 6, 11 and 15 and compared with 52 British adoptees.
Findings Those adopted before six months had a mean IQ of 102 at 11; those adopted after two years, 77. Children adopted after six months showed disinhibited attachment (clinginess, attention-seeking towards any adult).
Conclusion The effects of institutionalisation depend on age at adoption; some can be reversed with early good care.
Evaluation Real-life natural experiment with few confounding variables, so strong internal validity; Romanian institutions were unusually poor; long-term adult outcomes still unknown; led to changes in adoption practice.
Examiners say 'State two effects of institutionalisation' wants the terms: disinhibited attachment and intellectual disability (low IQ), with physical underdevelopment and poor parenting as alternatives.
Hazan and Shaver (1987), love quiz
Aim To test whether early attachment type predicts adult romantic relationships.
Method 620 replies to a newspaper 'love quiz' assessing current relationships, love experiences and attachment type.
Findings 56% secure, 25% avoidant, 19% resistant; secure adults reported good, lasting relationships; avoidant adults feared intimacy.
Conclusion The internal working model from infancy influences adult relationships.
Evaluation Retrospective self-report on childhood attachment; volunteer sample; correlational; supported by Bailey et al for parenting and McCarthy for friendships.
Examiners say Application questions about a person 'scared of commitment' expect avoidant type, the internal working model and the research named.
Work with an AQA psychology tutor
Know the studies but not scoring on the essays? That's what a tutor fixes.