Approaches in psychology: key studies
9 studies. Tap a card to flip it, then say whether you knew it. Cards you miss come back every round; cards you know come back less often. Progress is saved in this browser. Terms deck · Match-up game · Back to the topic
Wundt (1879), introspection
Aim To study the mind scientifically.
Method Opened the first psychology laboratory in Leipzig; trained participants reported their conscious experience of controlled stimuli (e.g. a ticking metronome) broken into thoughts, images and sensations, under standardised conditions.
Findings Introspection produced structured descriptions of experience (structuralism).
Conclusion Psychology could be separated from philosophy and studied with systematic methods.
Evaluation Standardised procedures were an early step towards science; introspection is subjective and unreplicable, so Watson rejected it; later approaches made psychology more scientific (behaviourism, cognitive neuroscience).
Examiners say 'Outline the emergence of psychology as a science' was answered poorly: name Wundt, the lab, introspection, and how later approaches used experiments.
Pavlov (1927), classical conditioning
Aim To study learning by association.
Method Dogs were presented with a bell (neutral stimulus) just before food (unconditioned stimulus), which produced salivation (unconditioned response); after repeated pairings the bell alone was presented and salivation measured.
Findings The bell became a conditioned stimulus producing salivation as a conditioned response.
Conclusion A neutral stimulus paired with an unconditioned stimulus comes to produce the same response: learning by association.
Evaluation Controlled and objective; generalisation, discrimination and extinction were also shown; animal findings may not transfer to humans in full.
Examiners say Use the labels UCS, UCR, NS, CS, CR accurately; reports note a minority who mix them up.
Skinner (1953), operant conditioning
Aim To study learning by consequences.
Method Rats or pigeons in a Skinner box pressed a lever; the consequence was manipulated: a food pellet (positive reinforcement), switching off an electric shock (negative reinforcement) or a shock (punishment).
Findings Reinforced behaviour increased in frequency; punished behaviour decreased; schedules of reinforcement affected persistence.
Conclusion Behaviour is shaped by its consequences.
Evaluation Highly controlled; shows cause and effect; generalising from rats is limited; the approach is environmentally determinist.
Examiners say Outline for 3 marks: the apparatus, what the animal did, the consequence and the effect. Application questions (litter in the playground) want the type of reinforcement named and a specific reward.
Bandura (1961), Bobo doll
Aim To test whether children learn aggression by observing a model.
Method 72 children aged 3–6 watched an adult either attack or ignore a Bobo doll, then were mildly frustrated and left with the doll.
Findings Children who saw the aggressive model were far more aggressive, imitating specific acts; boys were more physically aggressive, especially with a male model.
Conclusion Behaviour can be learned by observation and imitation, without direct reinforcement.
Evaluation Controlled laboratory procedure; the Bobo doll is designed to be hit, so demand characteristics are likely; children may have thought aggression was expected; the 1963 follow-up showed vicarious reinforcement.
Examiners say 'Describe how Bandura investigated social learning' needs the procedure; a limitation needs development: the doll invites hitting, so aggression may not reflect real learning.
Bandura (1963), vicarious reinforcement
Aim To see whether consequences to the model affect imitation.
Method Children watched a filmed model being rewarded, punished or receiving no consequence for aggression.
Findings Children who saw the model rewarded imitated most; those who saw punishment imitated least.
Conclusion Vicarious reinforcement: observing a model being rewarded increases imitation.
Evaluation Supports social learning theory's mediational processes; same artificiality as the original.
Examiners say Application (an advert using a rugby player) wants identification and vicarious reinforcement explained.
Tulving et al (1994), cognitive neuroscience
Aim To locate memory processes in the brain.
Method PET scans while participants performed episodic and semantic memory tasks.
Findings Episodic and semantic memories were associated with different areas of the prefrontal cortex.
Conclusion Cognitive processes have a biological basis that can be studied with brain imaging.
Evaluation Combines scientific objectivity with cognitive theory; imaging shows association, not necessarily cause.
Examiners say 'Outline what is meant by cognitive neuroscience' for 4 marks: the scientific study of the brain structures underlying mental processes, using imaging, with an example such as Tulving or Broca.
Twin studies and the biological approach
Aim To estimate the influence of genes on behaviour.
Method Comparing concordance rates for identical (MZ) and non-identical (DZ) twins.
Findings Higher MZ than DZ concordance suggests a genetic contribution; less than 100% MZ concordance shows environmental influence.
Conclusion Behaviour results from genotype expressed through environment as phenotype.
Evaluation Twins share environments too; MZ twins are treated more alike; adoption studies help separate the two.
Examiners say Stem questions about identical twins with different fillings, skin or attitudes want genotype (same genes) and phenotype (expression shaped by environment) applied.
Freud (1900s), psychodynamic approach
Aim To explain behaviour through unconscious processes.
Method Case studies (Little Hans), dream analysis and free association.
Findings The mind has conscious, preconscious and unconscious levels; the personality has the id (pleasure principle, present at birth), ego (reality principle, mediates), and superego (morality principle, formed at the phallic stage); psychosexual stages (oral, anal, phallic, latency, genital) with fixation if conflicts are unresolved; defence mechanisms (repression, denial, displacement) protect the ego.
Conclusion Early childhood experiences and unconscious conflicts shape adult personality.
Evaluation Explained the origins of personality and led to psychotherapy; concepts are unfalsifiable (Popper); based on single case studies; psychic determinism; gender bias.
Examiners say Describe the ego and superego with their principles and when they develop. Defence-mechanism stems (Jed's detention and kicking the dog) are well answered: name displacement and explain the redirected emotion.
Rogers (1959) and Maslow (1943), humanistic approach
Aim To explain people as free agents striving to grow.
Method Theories and client-centred therapy rather than experiments.
Findings Maslow's hierarchy of needs ends in self-actualisation; Rogers: the self, the ideal self and congruence between them; conditions of worth imposed by parents create incongruence; unconditional positive regard in therapy reduces it.
Conclusion People have free will and an innate drive to self-actualise.
Evaluation Positive and holistic; led to counselling; untestable concepts and limited application; culturally biased towards individualist ideals.
Examiners say Karishma's low self-esteem despite high grades: name incongruence (gap between actual and ideal self) and how a therapist offers unconditional positive regard. Reports say this was done poorly.
Work with an AQA psychology tutor
Know the studies but not scoring on the essays? That's what a tutor fixes.